WELCOME STUDENTS!

This is a place for us to discuss openly and honestly the literature we are reading. Here we are all just communicating our thoughts on what we are reading. There are no right and wrong answers. However, you are expected to be polite, mature, and on topic.

Wednesday, August 13, 2014

Beneath the Dusty Words

We have briefly talked about a few themes in Montana 1948.  Among these themes are justice, coming of age, the presence of evil in everyone, abuse of power/position, and race relations.  Select one of these themes and briefly explain why you believe it to be significant in this novel.  Give a quote that reveals that theme and tell how it does so.  (CATCH:  You may not write on the same theme as the two people prior to you.)  The deadline to post is midnight, Thursday, August 14, 2014)

2 comments:

Unknown said...

I believe that race relations is a major theme in the book. With it
Watson is able to show a glimpse at how America was still treating Native American Indians even after a hundred years of living with them in the same towns and houses. He incorporates it also into the other themes of the book, tying it together with justice, the evil in all people, and the abuse of power. "What the hell am I supposed to think? Screwing an Indian. Or feeling her up or whatever. You don't lock a man up for that. You don't lock up your own brother. A respected man. A war hero." (120) In these sentences, Watson shows how Julian's racism towards Indians makes him believe that it is alright for a respected, war hero to sexually assault a Sioux woman.

Unknown said...

I honestly believe that justice and abuse of power tie together as themes of this book. In Julian's younger years, he was the sheriff. Generally, a sheriff abides by the laws and works for what is right. He then begins to feel almighty and powerful due to his many years in office. Over time he gets more and more big-headed about all of this power. An example of this in the book on page sixty five when Frank explains to Gail the 'hilarious' story of Julian pulling a gun on the city boy. Julian sais "Now you head on out of here and you better hope the snow covers your tracks because I'm going to finish this whiskey and then I'm coming after you.", this quote shows that Julian is not afraid of getting in trouble because he has already got so much power. In the end of the novel, he abuses his power to bend the law and set his son free, which is not true justice.