WELCOME STUDENTS!

This is a place for us to discuss openly and honestly the literature we are reading. Here we are all just communicating our thoughts on what we are reading. There are no right and wrong answers. However, you are expected to be polite, mature, and on topic.

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Looking for a Hero

It seems all societies, no matter how ancient, have sought heroes. Define a hero. Which hero--the Anglo-Saxon Beowulf or the Medieval Sir Gawain--did you find most heroic by your definition?  Why?  (The deadline to post a response to this blog question is midnight Friday, September 30, 2011.)

5 comments:

Aaron Bermond said...

I believe a hero is someone who's standards and actions inspire others to do what is just. I feel as though Gawain was more of a hero by my standards. He went on his quest to maintain his honor, not simply for fame and glory, which seem to be selfish qualities. He was also humbled by the experience which made all the more admirable.

Joseph J said...

In my opinion, a hero is someone who does right no matter what. A hero is a person who will do a job nobody else will do but needs to be done. This applies to both small tasks and huge quests. In my opinion Beowulf is the better hero, because, although they both had equally heroic quests, Gawain did not truly know what he was getting into, whereas Beowulf knew exactly what he was up against. Gawain thgouht that he could just lop off a guys head and it would be done with. Beowulf knew he would have to fight terrible monsters, even at his old age.

Mikey said...

I hero is someone who fights for the well-being of a specific group of people. Beowulf was more heroic than Sir Gawain because he actually fought to benefit a group of people. Sir Gawain fought to bring himself honor.

Dillon said...

A hero is someone who binds there actions to moral values, honor and the hero does deeds for others, not for the fame, but because they are good. To me, Sir Gawain was more of a hero because he was moral, and he bound himself to the code of chivalry. Also, during his quest, Sir Gawain upheld his moral values during his stay with the king whom he made the deal with to give all his rewards in return for the king to give Sir Gawain all the meat from the days. hunt. Even though Sir Gawain kept the sasch given to him, his actions were not out of greed, but out of the desperation to preserve his own life.

TiffanyT said...

A hero is someone who does whatever he can to better the world around him. I find sir gawain to be a better hero because he is more realistic. He shows human qualiies unlike Beowulf and, therefore, can be related to.