WELCOME STUDENTS!

This is a place for us to discuss openly and honestly the literature we are reading. Here we are all just communicating our thoughts on what we are reading. There are no right and wrong answers. However, you are expected to be polite, mature, and on topic.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

"You are worth more than the whole damn bunch of them..."

Nick told us in the very beginning of the novel that he reserved judgments, but the last time he saw Gatsby alive he shouted to him "You are worth more than the whole damn bunch of them..." Nick has been our eyes, our ears, and our conscience through this novel.  When he makes this judgment, is he accurate?  What one event led you to agree or disagree with this assessment?  ( The deadline to post a response to this question is midnight, Thursday, February 13, 2014.)

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Although Nick is making a judgment here, he is strictly making it towards Gatsby. It does not change his honest perspective on the story he tells. I definitely think the statement he presents is true. He is simply being honest to a man who is down. Nick knows everything from every side so he is capable of making this statement without truly "judging." For instance Nick has witnesses Tom physically abuse Myrtle, the woman who he is cheating on with his wife. It is obvious that Gatsby is twice the man that Tom is presented as there. Also, even though Gatsby may love Daisy, she is nothing but a cowardly puppeteer. Gatsby makes her happy, but she does not want to actually leave Tom, for he is her safe spot. Gatsby is bold and a good man. Nicks statement that Gatsby is better than the bunch of them is extremely accurate.

Tiffany Bates said...

Personally, I do think Nick is being accurate to say that Gatsby is better than the "rotten bunch." Perhaps it is his personally judgement, but in my eyes, he is absolutely right. Gatsby gives to others (parties, new dresses, taking care of his parents) and only gets branded as a murderer that was justifiably murdered. Gatsby does nothing but give throughout the novel and all he wants...is Daisy. My heart aches for poor Gatsby and the dream that is already behind him, but the one situation that proved it to me was when Gatsby took the blame upon himself after Daisy killed Myrtle. He was willing to do anything for that conniving and conceited witch and what happens to him because of it? He is murdered. He is such a good guy and it is depressing that the good guy dies and nobody cares (except Nick and Gatsby's father, of course). He takes the blame and gets nothing in return from Daisy or anyone. He is better than "the whole damn bunch of them" and I agree with Nick's judgement completely.

KG Block 1 said...

I believe that when Nick makes this judgement, he is very accurate. Daisy just runs away with Tom in the end and Tom just blames it on Gatsby. Gatsby means no harm to anyone throughout the novel. He is simply trying to win the heart of the girl that took his breath away from the very first kiss. Nick realizes how selfless Gatsby is. With that realization and the terrible actions of Tom and Daisy, he is correct in saying that Gatsby is better than all of them, due to the fact that Gatsby is trying to win Daisy with the purity of his heart.